I finally had an opportunity to see Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 last week. A few people who know that I’m a huge fan of the character of Mantis were curious what I thought of how she was used in the movie.
I might as well mention that Steve Englehart, who created Mantis in 1973, was “not happy” at how Mantis was depicted in GOTG 2. I can understand Englehart’s perspective on this. Mantis is a character that he wrote on various occasions over a 35 year span. He invested a great deal of time and energy into developing Mantis. She is obviously very important to him.
Indeed, that is the primary reason why Mantis is one of my all time favorite characters. Englehart clearly put a great deal of thought into her, in the process creating a very interesting character with a wonderfully bizarre origin and an exciting, offbeat story arc.
So I realize that it must have been disappointing for Englehart that GOTG 2 writer / director James Gunn did not adhere closely to the original conception of the character.
Nevertheless, looking at it from my perspective as a reader and a longtime fan of the character, I felt that the translation of Mantis from page to screen was rather successful. Visually she looked amazing. The concept design of Mantis that artist Andy Park created for the movie was very faithful to the original character while also working as something that was both visually effective and functional in live action. Mantis was played by Pom Klementieff, a well-regarded, talented actress who did great work with the material.
I admit that I was somewhat disappointed that certain aspects of Mantis from the original Marvel Comics stories were neglected or altered. She was too passive; I would have liked for her to be a more assertive individual. I also wanted to see her utilizing martial arts. Klementieff previously displayed a real adeptness at dynamic fight sequences in the 2013 movie Oldboy, so hopefully she will be able to bring that skill to her portrayal of Mantis in future installments.
Nevertheless, in spite of Gunn perhaps not utilizing the character Mantis as well as he might have, she made an interesting addition to GOTG 2. I definitely enjoyed her interaction with Drax. Gunn’s dialogue for these scenes was both funny and poignant. Klementieff and Dave Bautista played very well off one another.
Actually, as someone who has seen many of the entries in the “Marvel Cinematic Universe,” I think Mantis is much closer to the source material than some other characters. Looking at the two GOTG movies from Gunn, the characters of Drax, Gamora, Groot and Yondu are all quite different from their comic book versions, but they each worked very well.
On the other hand, if you look at the second and third Iron Man movies, the villains Justin Hammer and the Mandarin were almost nothing like the original comic book characters. In both cases this was definitely to the detriment of the movies.
Sometimes fans do not realize how difficult it can be to adapt comic books into movies. They are two different mediums, each with their own sensibilities. What works in one might not in the other. This requires a delicate balancing act by filmmakers, as they attempt to remain faithful to the source material while simultaneously determining how to make these characters & stories work in a two hour live action movie. Some filmmakers are more successful at this than others; Gunn is one of the better ones.
Even though the specifics of Mantis in GOTG 2 were altered, personally speaking I did feel that she was quite true to the spirit of the character Steve Englehart created. I enjoyed seeing her in GOTG 2, and I am look forward to seeing Pom Klementieff reprise the role in Avengers: Infinity War.